Thursday, 23 June 2011

Pear Shaped…….?




Watching the on-going saga in Europe with Greece on the edge of the cliff I can’t help but think of September/October 2008.  The similarities between the situations, while very different, are at the same time incredible!

If you throw your mind back to the week-end of 13th/14th September Lehman Brothers was on the edge – the stock had fallen from $16/share to $3.65 over the course of the week – rumours about them were abundant – it was the no 1 story on CNBC and so on. Much like Greece right now.

Similar to what has been going on in Europe over the last 12 months; Bear Stearns had failed, but had received a bail-out orchestrated by the Fed and the Treasury. Guarantees were issued to JP Morgan, which made the takeover possible, and no creditor incurred a loss. While Lehman’s stock price was tanking, the market (me included) still believed that some sort of solution would be found. The NY Fed even called banks on Friday afternoon to tell them that a solution would be found over the weekend. Risk assets had a moderate recovery into the close.

Now we have politicians and central bankers telling the market that no euro-zone member will ever default and that everything will be fine, while every astute market commentator will argue that Greece will default – it’s just a question of time as the debt levels are simply too high to be sustained, let alone repaid.

Bond holders are being asked to roll over their maturing Greek government bonds (GGBs), but not at market yields, so while their very short term bonds will be redeemed at par the holders are being asked to buy new issues with a coupon much lower than secondary market yields, which range form the high 20’ies to the mid-teens depending on the place on the yield curve. Credit agencies say this will constitute a default, which the politicians and the ECB are desperate to avoid. Holders of Greek CDS may, or may not be compensated, which in itself may become a huge problem for certain investors who thought they had purchased insurance against their bond holdings.

It is of course ironic that we live in a world where banks can book gains when the value of the banks own debt falls in value, but at the same time can carry e.g. Greek government bonds at cost (i.e. no mark to market) so some of the most profitable banks at the moment could be Greek and Portuguese banks as the value of their own liabilities are reflecting the assets they hold, but these assets are not being marked down in these banks financial statements!

So what will happen? The most likely is probably that Greece will be funded by the euro zone and the IMF until a time when a restructuring can happen with the vast majority of the debt in the hands of the ECB, EMSF, IMF etc and the need to recapitalize French and German banks will be much smaller and hopefully everything will be much better then and of course it will be someone else’s problem……this is a typical politician’s vision: Things will be better in the future. But what if they are not, or what if we don’t even get to the future? I think this is not as un-likely as the market has been believing!

Further Greek assistance is dependent on further austerity measures being introduced and these are certainly not popular, judging by the protests in the streets in Athens. Nor is further assistance popular with many of the voters in the countries, which are meant to foot the bill. Can this balance be achieved? Maybe, maybe not. There are a lot of variables that have to be observed:

  • ·      Austerity measures have to be passed by the Greek parliament. The main opposition party have indicated that they will vote against these;
  • ·      Politicians/voters in Germany, Holland and Finland have to be placated so the austerity measures cannot be watered down;
  • ·      The next tranche of the IMF support package cannot be released if there isn’t a clear 12 month funding plan;
  • ·      Private investors have to be strong-armed into rolling their maturing bonds over into new ones with sub-market coupons and yields. This will result in instantaneous losses of approximately 50% (depending a bit on maturity);
  • ·      Default is to be avoided or GGBs will no longer be eligible as collateral with the ECB and the result would be that Greek banks would be illiquid and another bank run would ensue;
  • ·      ISDA would need to accept this so a credit event is not declared;
  • ·      Losses incurred by holders of GGBs would not be covered by CDS so they would presumably lose twice i.e. the GGB loss + the premium on the CDS, which in itself might prove worthless;


There are probably a few more things I haven’t thought about, but all this is not easy to accomplish.

Is the market ready for a default? Probably not!

What will happen? Greek banks will be instantly bankrupt and will need to be recapitalized/nationalized. Greece will of course have to leave the Euro and reintroduce the drachma.

Some French and German banks may need to be re-capitalized. The inter-bank market, which hasn’t recovered from the events of 2008/09, will freeze. The pressure on Portugal and Ireland, which is already intense as their 10 year government spreads are at EMU-time highs, will become much worse, closely followed by the ones which are too big to bail-out; Spain and Italy. This is of course why everyone who has political capital invested in this is afraid of ‘contagion’.

Then it may be all over – the euro zone experiment may have ended 12 ½ years after it begun.

So while the politicians and central bankers thought a solution would be found for Lehman over that fatal weekend in September 2008 it wasn’t. Greece may have a little more time than Lehman did, but if a solution hasn’t been hammered out by early July it may truly be all over!

Thursday, 21 April 2011

Inflation, Inflation, Inflation……


So now everyone is on the band-wagon with inflation going up because of rising commodity costs, which are rising because of QE2, which is the Fed’s undoing of all things good….,or is it?

Woody Brock and David Rosenberg have both just penned great pieces on this topic so I will keep it short.

Headline inflation (CPI) in the UK is now 4%, but at least 75bps is a direct result of VAT going up to 20% from 17.5% according the National Statistics Office and this analysis was done for the month of January. One could argue that the effect is larger now – the CPI indices without taxation (CPI-Y) and with constant taxation are running at or around 2.7%, so the ‘truth’ is somewhere in between the two (2.7% - 3.25%). Is this runaway inflation? No! Is it high considering the recent movements in the oil price which in £ terms went to all-time highs? No, not at all.

One of the other commodities feeding into CPI, which has gone up in spectacular fashion is Cotton. Cotton has risen from around 75c/lb to more than $2/lb before retracing back to $1.78/lb. This has caused major pain for the producers of items made of cotton and for retailers. Hennes & Mauritz reported 30% lower earnings in Q1 as they absorbed the price increase rather than passing it on to their customers.

So far so good. Then I took a look at the futures curve……I don’t recall EVER having seen anything like it: It’s not just in backwardation which means that prices are lower the further out the curve you go – they are a lot lower! May 2012 is 80c lower than May 2011, so while futures prices are not really a ‘prediction’ of where prices will be in the future they are certainly a point at which the manufacturers and retailers can purchase the Cotton they will need for some of their future production.

Of course inflation only ever really becomes a problem when the so-called second round effects take hold and the whole thing becomes a vicious cycle with everything going up and workers are able to ask for higher wages to reflect the higher prices etc.

So if Cotton is a good predictor of future inflation then I’d say we have seen the worst.

Friday, 26 November 2010

Ireland – the solution for the Irish?


At the moment the Irish government and the ECB/EU/MF are hammering out a deal which will see Ireland borrowing approximately €85 bill primarily to bail out its bankrupt banking system – the government is only really in dire straits because it has to bail out a banking system whose assets had grown to 700% of GDP[1]. By comparison the US banking system has assets of roughly 100% of GDP.

If I were an Irish (opposition) politician in the upcoming general election I would run my campaign on a “no” to this so-called bail out and ask: Why should a generation be paying for this? What will stop any able-bodied Irish man or woman leaving Ireland now? The size of the bail-out will increase Irish government debt by 40-45% of GDP in one quick move.

The reality behind the urgency was the markets waking up to fact that Ireland could not afford to keep its pledge to guarantee all senior obligations of its banks, which swiftly brings us to the next question:

Is €85 bill even enough? Who knows? Two (out of four) of the troubled Irish banks actually passed the ECB’s stress test earlier on in the year, which just goes to show how good and reliable they were…..! With €1.4 trillion is assets between the banks how much has actually been/will be lost?

As a would-be Irish popular politician I would say that the bailout is mainly to let the people of Ireland pay for the mistakes made in London, Frankfurt and other financial centres where its actually the mistakes of the holders of the Irish banks senior debt that are being bailed out! Chancellor Merkel is quite keen on making ‘those who profit’ pay when it comes to sovereign debt restructuring – so how about just letting the senior bond holders pay? The banks taking the losses can go to the markets and try and raise the capital they have just lost and if necessary Ms Merkel can underwrite the German banks so they don’t default. Why should the Irish tax-payer pay for a bail out of the UK and German banks?

I would guarantee the domestic deposits and re-incarnate the banks to service the domestic economy (much like they had to do in Iceland) if need be leave the Euro, re-introduce the punt take a devaluation as it’s much less painful than an internal devaluation, which is the result of the current policies and get on with it! Of course I would keep the 12.5% corporation tax rate and negotiate directly with any inward investor who might lose money as a result of the banks defaulting, but paying for the UK and German banks’ mistakes – no way!

Will you vote for me??????


[1] According to research by Barclays Capital

Friday, 5 November 2010

QE2 came and it’s off to the races, but what’s going on in Europe?


While it looks like the risk-on trade is in full flow with the interesting concept of all assets going up in tandem – something I find unsustainable – but never mind.

In the middle of the euphoria the crisis in Europe is coming back even if it doesn’t get much attention in the media. Irish 10 year spreads just blew out to a new all time high against bunds, €/CHF looks like it could break down and most likely will if 1.3550 is given (it just was so the recovery in €/CHF seems to be over), the Ibex doesn’t look like it’s in rally mode, quite the opposite, so can the rest of the markets just ignore this and continue as if nothing’s happening in the European corner? Somehow I don’t think so…….

Friday, 8 October 2010

The correlation between markets & QE II……..

The markets have become more and more correlated with the risk-on/risk-off trade (interesting article about this topic in the FT yesterday - link here: http://www.ft.com/, but one thing has changed: the equity markets and the US in particular has been able to shrug off bad news while embracing the good news….
This in itself has happened before and in particular it reminds me of the mind-set from the autumn of 2007 where one CNBC market commentator phrased it something like “if we get bad economic data, the Fed will lower rates and that will be good for stocks….” I think he managed, in the same report to say that the stock market was a forward looking market…
So fast forward till the autumn of 2010 - treasuries are approaching all time low yields (some parts of the curve have already traded through the previous lows) because of disappointing economic data and the anticipation of QE II, while the stock market manages to rally albeit not to new highs on the same information. 
Warren Buffett is out again talking about how cheap the stock market is (and how expensive the bond market is) - personally he did that trade in October 2008 - His op-ed was published on 16th October 2008 in the New York Times so for a little fun experiment, I have compared the returns of a US treasury bond index and the S&P 500 from that date till yesterday’s close (7th October) and the results are surprising……...think about it purchase of US equities in the middle of a massive bear market compared to an index of US treasuries. Which performed better? 
Oct 2008 - Oct 2010:       S&P 500                   +22.36%
                                             Treasuries           +22.90%
So in my book they have had the same performance, but think about the difference in volatility and the asset classes - the “riskiest” vs the “safest” - I have put both in quotation marks as it’s not obvious that everyone agrees about the relative risk or safety of either, but at least traditionally that’s how they were perceived. Any money manager would, at least in hind-sight, have kept the treasuries.
The real point I am trying to make is that the current scenario where good news is good news and bad news is also good news (for equities) may come to an end - some members of the FOMC are making their views known that QE II is not a foregone conclusion and any reasonable participant should question the fact that the QE I in large part has just ended up in excess reserves - so why would more of the same work better?
The markets most at risk are perversely, in my view, not treasuries, but gold and equities, which have been rallying on the back of QE II leading to inflation, while treasuries are rallying on a basis of QE II coming, or not, not leading to inflation - all three cannot continue to rally together!

Friday, 20 August 2010

Inflation.....and bond yields!

Following last week’s inflation report from The Bank of England this week’s actual inflation report for July came in much as expected with the headline CPI dropping to 3.1% Y/Y from 3.2% in June.
Because of my recent foray into the media about inflation and the economy I have been paying closer attention to UK inflation and the underlying factors driving it. What no-one seems to notice, or care about, except for the B of E is that CPIY i.e. inflation without indirect taxes and in particular without VAT fell from 1.6% Y/Y to 1.4%. 
This is the measure  we should focus on as the VAT decrease in 2009 followed by the increase in 2010, which will be followed by anther increase in 2011 will make it impossible for anyone to deduct anything from the headline CPI number - anyone who says differently is either stupid or lying, or both! 
This was also the case in 2009 when CPI was much lower than CPI-Y as the effect of the temporary VAT reduction fed through to CPI. What is more interesting is that CPI-Y has continued to fall from the peak of just over 5% in 2008 to the current level of 1.4%, albeit not in a straight line, the trend is clear......lower! 
Even the inflationists favorite measure the RPI, when stripping out the VAT effects etc and looking at the RPIY fell from 3.8% Y/Y to 3.5%.

Elsewhere it is deflation that's staring policy makers in the face - The Fed is clearly worried and it probably won't be long before QE2 light will be replaced by a fully fledged version somewhere between $500 billion and $1 trillion. Philly Fed's survey which was released yesterday at -7 instead of the expected +7 and weekly jobless claims topping 500k again.  

Recovery? Has it been and gone already?
In the bond markets yields are reflecting the very weak economic backdrop (even if the equity market participants are not fully embracing this reality) and with US mortgage yields in deep re-financing territory (all the ones who can will refinance) the negative convexity is playing havoc with duration i.e. If you need/want duration the only place to go really is the back end of the yield curve, which is why it’s starting to flatten smartly and will probably continue to do so as 2 year yields below 50 bp’s hardly provides any protection or yield, 30 years at 3.60-something is the place to be. 10-30’s is still north of 100 bp’s and that could easily come back into the 50-75 bp range during the remainder of this year. It could go even lower depending on the launch of the new QE2 and the scope/weighting of it.
All the bond-bubble alarmists will be hurting emotionally (financially as well if they put their money where there mouths are) as the market will continue to rally and the curve continues to flatten......but the more of them there are the better for the market’s prospects as short covering is a very powerful thing.....! 

If you care for a more thorough trashing of the latest bond-bubble alarmists' arguments then you should read David Rosenberg's daily comment from yesterday.....it's very good reading indeed!

Wednesday, 11 August 2010

Interesting day....

Having spent the morning appearing on no less then three BBC radio programmes including the Today program as well as the BBC Business Report on BBC World, it has given me  a reminder of how little time general news actually gives to financial/business news.
Trying to debate the Fed’s actions last night  and the implications of QE, the prospects for growth and inflation globally and specifically in the UK in slots of 3 mins or less is very difficult and the generalizations become huge!
So what do I think? The Fed’s announcement that they would keep the balance sheet at current levels by re-investing mortgage backed coupons and redemptions in treasuries is, I’m sure better than not doing it, but is it just rearranging the deck chairs on the Titanic? It could well be, as the base case looks more and more like a double-dip - I out the odds at 50/50 this morning, but even if we don’t technically get a double-dip growth will be very sluggish for a long time.
I did a little digging on UK inflation data last night in preparation of my media appearances this morning and found that CPI-Y (that is CPI without indirect taxes such as VAT) is actually quite stable and currently running at 1.6% Y/Y, which is what the Bank of England should be focusing on when they talk to the markets and the media. Their mandate may be headline CPI, but they cannot be held responsible for, or even asked to take this into account when it is the government that is responsible for half the current annual growth in CPI i.e. taxes.
While the MPC always say they are looking ‘through’ the temporary effects of indirect taxation and the effective depreciation of sterling, why don’t they start talking about the CPI-Y, or the net-price index as I would call it ?????
Well, they can of course start that today at the press conference and if they do I will be taking all the credit!
I had the pleasure of meeting Andrew Lilico from the Policy Exchange before and after our debate on the Today program and while he thinks the economy will be weak in the short term and that more QE is forthcoming as well, but then our views are very different as Andrew believes that growth in the second half of 2011 will take off sharply and inflation will follow. I completely disagree as I see no growth of any significance in a scenario where the government is cutting expenditure aggressively and the banking system is still broken and the shadow banking system has ceased to exist. There can be no growth without access to credit, unless it’s government sponsored.
Bond markets seem to be continuing to take the cue and rally to this new economic reality, but equity markets are completely mis-priced, why on earth they think that corporate profitability can continue to grow in a no-, or low growth economy is beyond me. There are only so many costs and jobs that can be cut - and while these cost saving measures may be good for an individual company’s short-term profitability, they are terrible for the economy as a whole. The difference is that bond markets can be a leading indicator, while the equity market is clueless........!